Current:Home > FinanceDonald Trump back in court today as New York fraud trial nears end-DB Wealth Institute B2 Expert Reviews
Donald Trump back in court today as New York fraud trial nears end
View Date:2024-12-24 21:04:10
Former President Donald Trump is back in court to attend proceedings Thursday in his New York civil fraud trial as his defense questioned its final expert witness on the stand.
Trump has attended the trial, which began on Oct. 2, eight previous times — including for his Nov. 6 testimony. That day, he clashed with the judge, Arthur Engoron, straying from questions and earning reprimands.
Trump, two of his sons and their company are accused of participating in a decade-long fraud scheme involving vast misrepresentations of Trump's wealth to attract favorable rates on loans and insurance. They have all denied wrongdoing in the case. Eric Trump joined his father in court on Thursday.
Thursday's testimony
The former president listened as his attorney questioned Eli Bartov, a New York University accounting professor who testified about the role of property valuations in financial statements that are at the heart of the fraud case. He said that he saw "no evidence whatsoever for accounting fraud," and that the statements of financial condition "were not materially misstated."
"So your expert opinion is, from an accounting perspective, the attorney general's complaint had no merit?" the judge asked.
"This is absolutely [my] opinion, yes," Bartov replied.
Bartov also acknowledged that the value of Trump's penthouse in Trump Tower in Manhattan was "inflated" in his financial statement, but attributed the discrepancy to "an error in the calculation," which he said was "not unusual." Forbes magazine revealed in 2017 that Trump's three-story apartment was about a third of the size he had long claimed — about 11,000 square feet, instead of more than 30,000 — and thus far less valuable.
Kevin Wallace, a lawyer for New York Attorney General Letitia James, said Bartov's opinions weren't relevant to evidence presented at trial. He and another lawyer for James attacked Bartov's ability to render opinions on banking decisions and credit analysis related to private companies.
As Trump walked out of the courtroom during a mid-morning break, he stopped to review court artist Jane Rosenberg's sketch.
"Nice," he said, according to Rosenberg.
Moments later, he hailed a decision by an appellate court that extended an Oct. 6 order pausing the dissolution of Trump's company while the trial is ongoing. That order stemmed from a Sept. 26 pretrial ruling finding Trump and the company liable for fraud.
"I think it's a great thing for the country, a very strong decision by the Appellate Division, just getting down this moment," Trump said. "That decision is very powerful."
His attorney Christopher Kise also lauded the decision in a statement to CBS News.
"President Trump very much appreciates the court's consideration and ruling today. The ruling helps pave the way for a much needed, and deliberative, review of the trial court's many errors," Kise said.
Tensions in the courtroom boiled over in the early afternoon after Wallace objected to some of Bartov's testimony, describing it as "pure speculation from someone they hired to say whatever it is they want."
"You really ought to be ashamed of yourself," Bartov replied, his voice rising. "You make up allegations that never existed. I am here to tell the truth. You should be ashamed of yourself, talking to me like that."
Bartov later offered testimony that reinforced Trump's own Nov. 6 testimony in this case, that the statements at the center of the case warned banks to use them at their own risk.
"This is like the warning of the surgeon general on a box of cigarettes," Bartov said.
He later described a disclaimer in the statements as meaning, "use your own analysis and come up with your own estimate."
"I never saw anything clearer than that, even my 9-year-old granddaughter … would understand that language," Bartov said.
The Trump fraud case
In the civil fraud trial, New York Attorney General Letitia James is seeking to claw back $250 million for the state, as well as sanctions against the defendants designed to severely limit their ability to do business in New York.
Trump has seethed at James outside the courtroom, including on Thursday, when he called her "crazy" and a "lunatic."
He and Engoron have also been at loggerheads since early in the trial, when Trump published a social media post attacking the judge's law clerk. The judge then imposed a limited gag order, which Trump raged against and twice violated, incurring $15,000 in fines.
Three of Trump's children, Donald Trump Jr., Eric Trump and Ivanka Trump, have also testified during the trial. The two sons are defendants in the case, but Ivanka Trump is not. She was originally a defendant, but the allegations against her were dismissed by an appellate court that ruled they were outside the statute of limitations.
Donald Trump himself is scheduled to be the final witness called in his own defense on Monday, Dec. 11.
- In:
- Donald Trump
Graham Kates is an investigative reporter covering criminal justice, privacy issues and information security for CBS News Digital. Contact Graham at [email protected] or [email protected]
veryGood! (65)
Related
- MLS Star Marco Angulo Dead at 22 One Month After Car Crash
- David Beckham talks family, Victoria doc and how Leonardo DiCaprio helped him win an Emmy
- Michigan deputy jumps into action to save 63-year-old man in medical emergency: Video
- 11-year-old charged after police say suspicious device brought on school bus in Maine
- New Orleans marks with parade the 64th anniversary of 4 little girls integrating city schools
- Biden is putting personal touch on Asia-Pacific diplomacy in his final months in office
- It was unique debut season for 212 MLB players during pandemic-altered 2020
- Two dead, three hurt after a shooting in downtown Minneapolis
- John Krasinski named People's Sexiest Man Alive for 2024
- Police chase in NYC, Long Island ends with driver dead and 7 officers, civilian taken to hospitals
Ranking
- Gold is suddenly not so glittery after Trump’s White House victory
- A lost cat’s mysterious 2-month, 900-mile journey home to California
- Gilmore Girls Star Kelly Bishop Shares Touching Memories of On-Screen Husband Ed Herrmann
- Newly Blonde Kendall Jenner Reacts to Emma Chamberlain's Platinum Hair Transformation
- Gigi Hadid and Bradley Cooper Prove They're Going Strong With Twinning Looks on NYC Date
- Moment of Sean Diddy Combs' Arrest Revealed in New Video
- Martha Stewart says 'unfriendly' Ina Garten stopped talking to her when she went to prison
- Extra 25% Off Everything at Kate Spade Outlet: Get a $500 Tote Set for $111, $26 Wallets, $51 Bags & More
Recommendation
-
Dwayne Johnson Admits to Peeing in Bottles on Set After Behavior Controversy
-
The politics of immigration play differently along the US-Mexico border
-
Alec Baldwin urges judge to stand by dismissal of involuntary manslaughter case in ‘Rust’ shooting
-
Why Bella Hadid Is Thanking Gigi Hadid's Ex Zayn Malik
-
Michael Jordan and driver Tyler Reddick come up short in bid for NASCAR championship
-
Motel 6 sold to Indian hotel operator for $525 million
-
Were warning signs ignored? Things to know about this week’s testimony on the Titan sub disaster
-
Video showing Sean 'Diddy' Combs being arrested at his hotel is released